Rabin panned the e-book saying that Ciccone implied their mother can be "horrified at Madonna's debauchery, but would feel proud her gay son wrote a ebook that prominently features him snorting cocaine with numerous super-celebrities". But a decide dismissed that, saying "any proper-thinking particular person" would discover the doll obscene. However, the relationship fully ended when Madonna accused him of theft from her in an email, "of swindling her after 20 years of being the only person that hadn't". In March 2019, the Justice Ministry revoked a deportation order for a gay Taiwanese man who had remained in Japan illegally after overstaying his visa, giving consideration to his longtime same-intercourse relationship with a Japanese national. Altman discovered that ultimately the publication was relegated to providing "a peek at a man still grappling together with his sister's dizzying fame". In 2013, Cardinal Keith O'Brien, the Archbishop of Saint Andrews and Edinburgh, resigned following publication of allegations he had engaged in inappropriate and predatory sexual conduct with priests and seminarians beneath his jurisdiction and abused his energy. An auction was held amongst quite a few publication homes, and Simon Spotlight Entertainment lastly accepted to launch the ebook.

Rosenberg clarified that Madonna realized her relationship with Ciccone was damaged irreparably, and that the discharge of the e book ended any probability of the siblings ever reconciling. She believed that Ciccone might have gone all the best way in writing about particulars that nobody knew, however as a substitute chose to reflect unsuccessfully on his relationship with Madonna. Previous to the discharge of the guide, the connection between Madonna and Ciccone had deteriorated from 2001 onwards, when Madonna refused to make use of him as her tour director for the Drowned World Tour. Giles Hattersley from The Times commended Ciccone's want to release a inform-all memoir, however believed that he failed, since the vast majority of the book confirmed bitterness at by no means being higher than Madonna. Barbara Ellen from The Observer referred to as it Ciccone's "missed alternative" at writing a "misery memoir", feeling a greater title for the book would have been "Sissie Dearest". The ebook ends with an epilogue listing the singer's accomplishments and Ciccone's current life, in addition to an afterword, the place he detailed how Madonna supposedly wished to stop the publishing of the guide and beforehand unreleased family photographs.

Alex Altman from Time noted that the memoir was targeted much less on Madonna but relatively on Ciccone's life, self-described because the singer's "doormat". On August 7, the Daily Collegian, the scholar paper on the University of Massachusetts Amherst, lit a fuse that may explode the sleepy major race in Massachusetts’ 1st District between Holyoke Mayor Alex Morse and incumbent Rep. Writing for The Daily Telegraph, John Preston famous that the failure of the e-book was Ciccone's inability to move past his obsession with Madonna, which resulted in the writing being insincere. But there's little question that Haggard is making an attempt to maneuver on and start to rebuild his life and previous career. Molly Friedman believed that Life with My Sister Madonna only helped to boost Madonna's repute as a "dangerous lady", which was missing from the singer's repertoire for a very long time. He believed that being underneath the shadow of Madonna had never allowed him to realize an identity of his personal. The singer did not discover out about the e-book being revealed till Ciccone had asked their father for household footage.

Club discovered the ebook to observe the general theme of inform-all releases by somebody bitter with Ciccone laying "out the case against his sister in a prosecutorial vogue", whereas involving their useless mother at any chance he bought. Susanah Cahalan from the new York Post was combined in her evaluation, pointing out the highlight of the book as when Ciccone described the enmity he felt for Madonna's husband Guy Ritchie, by painting him as a homophobe. They also felt that the e book revealed nothing noteworthy or not already widespread data. An article in New York felt that Ciccone would revenue from the e-book's sales, by including the identical content material that was already recognized in regards to the singer. Ciccone narrates the early a part of his life with Madonna, including his first joint and his first go to to a gay bar. She instantly emailed Ciccone to name her, which he refused to do. Ciccone described writing the e book as "an enormous fucking orgasm. Therapy I already had; this was pure allison williams sex scene". Ciccone wrote the book with author Wendy Leigh, who had previously written biographies of John F. Kennedy Jr., Prince Edward, and Liza Minnelli, and ghostwrote Zsa Zsa Gabor's autobiography.